Contact
Office
Coldwell Banker Northland
5200 E Cortland Blvd D1
Flagstaff AZ 86004
Katannya Hartwell, ABR®, RSPS, believes real estate should feel less like a transaction and more like a guided, grounded experience. Her clients often describe her as intuitive, steady, and quietly brilliant — someone who brings both clarity and care to every interaction.
A seasoned Realtor® based in Flagstaff, Arizona, Katannya offers a thoughtful and strategic approach to every sale. Whether helping someone purchase their first home, guiding a lifestyle-driven second property purchase, or navigating the sale of a one-of-a-kind mountain retreat, she brings calm focus, responsiveness, and a genuine commitment to her clients’ well-being.
Katannya began her real estate career in 2019 following a background in education, psychology, and small business ownership. These foundations shaped her ability to listen deeply, think creatively, and guide clients into aligned, empowered decisions — especially when evaluating distinctive or complex properties.
She also brings five years of experience in the vacation rental space through Bear Paw Comforts LLC, a hospitality business she helped grow. This hands-on knowledge gives her clients an advantage when assessing potential short-term rental investments or second homes in Flagstaff’s dynamic market.
As an Accredited Buyer’s Representative (ABR®) and Resort and Second-Home Property Specialist (RSPS), Katannya helps clients consider both the financial and lifestyle aspects of real estate. She approaches every relationship with presence, insight, and a calm determination to ensure the process feels as supportive and seamless as possible.
Outside of real estate, Katannya enjoys spending time with loved ones, exploring Flagstaff’s natural beauty, and studying the deeper patterns of life through Waldorf education and spiritual practice. Her work reflects not just professionalism, but a wholehearted commitment to helping people move forward with clarity and confidence.
Katannya is an honest and trustworthy realtor. She has been my property manager and also helped sell our home. Home selling is a stressful process, but she has been very supportive and has helped us throughout the entire process. Having us on our corner, representing us, and being honest with us was tremendously helpful.
Katannya is an honest and trustworthy realtor. She has been my property manager and also helped sell our home. Home selling is a stressful process, but she has been very supportive and has helped us throughout the entire process. Having us on our corner, representing us, and being honest with us was tremendously helpful.
My wife and I worked with Katannya to buy a place in Flagstaff a few years ago. She was a terrific agent, keeping us informed throughout negotiations, giving advice, and then even helping us find people to fix the place up after we bought it. Katannya is attentive, courteous, and hardworking. We are working with her!
My wife and I worked with Katannya to buy a place in Flagstaff a few years ago. She was a terrific agent, keeping us informed throughout negotiations, giving advice, and then even helping us find people to fix the place up after we bought it. Katannya is attentive, courteous, and hardworking. We are working with her!
Wonderful experience working with Katannya, we used her twice and would do so again! She was very professional and knowledgeable, and she took a lot of the stress out of our real estate transactions. She has a beautiful personality and was able to handle anything we threw at her with grace.
Wonderful experience working with Katannya, we used her twice and would do so again! She was very professional and knowledgeable, and she took a lot of the stress out of our real estate transactions. She has a beautiful personality and was able to handle anything we threw at her with grace.
Katannya is knowledgeable and professional while being kind and personable as well. She gave great care and attention while I was shopping for a home and was able to pick up on my wants that I hadn't even realized I had! I would recommend her to any home buyer in the Flagstaff area, and I look forward to working with her in the future.
Katannya is knowledgeable and professional while being kind and personable as well. She gave great care and attention while I was shopping for a home and was able to pick up on my wants that I hadn't even realized I had! I would recommend her to any home buyer in the Flagstaff area, and I look forward to working with her in the future.
I had an outstanding experience working with Katannya. She was incredibly helpful and attentive to my needs. Katannya went above and beyond in providing thorough research and information, answering all my questions in a timely manner.
I had an outstanding experience working with Katannya. She was incredibly helpful and attentive to my needs. Katannya went above and beyond in providing thorough research and information, answering all my questions in a timely manner.
Great agent for investment properties in the N Arizona market.
Great agent for investment properties in the N Arizona market.
So kind, knowledgeable, and helpful!
So kind, knowledgeable, and helpful!
Working with Ms. Flagstaff Real Estate was an exceptional experience from start to finish. Their team is incredibly knowledgeable about the Flagstaff market and went above and beyond to make the entire process smooth and stress-free. Whether you're a first-time home buyer, looking for investment property, or seeking luxury real estate in Northern Arizona, this is the real estate agency you want by your side. They listened to what I needed, respected my budget, and negotiated skillfully on my behalf. Truly some of the best real estate professionals in Flagstaff—I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone looking for a top Flagstaff realtor or a local real estate expert you can trust.
Working with Ms. Flagstaff Real Estate was an exceptional experience from start to finish. Their team is incredibly knowledgeable about the Flagstaff market and went above and beyond to make the entire process smooth and stress-free. Whether you're a first-time home buyer, looking for investment property, or seeking luxury real estate in Northern Arizona, this is the real estate agency you want by your side. They listened to what I needed, respected my budget, and negotiated skillfully on my behalf. Truly some of the best real estate professionals in Flagstaff—I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone looking for a top Flagstaff realtor or a local real estate expert you can trust.
Kat is the best agent in Flagstaff to refer to! She is always very diligent with helping my clients through the entire transaction, and she keeps me informed of the progress. I have worked with her multiple times, and successfully, too!
Kat is the best agent in Flagstaff to refer to! She is always very diligent with helping my clients through the entire transaction, and she keeps me informed of the progress. I have worked with her multiple times, and successfully, too!
She is the best realtor when it comes to connecting California and Arizona. If you want to make the move from California to beautiful Flagstaff, Arizona, she will take care of you. She has been assisting not only the locals but also people transitioning to the new area. She is a top-notch realtor, truly.
She is the best realtor when it comes to connecting California and Arizona. If you want to make the move from California to beautiful Flagstaff, Arizona, she will take care of you. She has been assisting not only the locals but also people transitioning to the new area. She is a top-notch realtor, truly.
Be the First to See What’s New
Sold on March 3, 2025
$1,125,000
6710 Silver Saddle Road, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Courtesy of Paula A Giovannitti with Redfin Corporation
Sold on July 8, 2026
$1,100,000
39291 Lake Mary Road, Happy Jack, AZ 86024
Courtesy of Coldwell Banker Northland
Sold on October 25, 2024
$750,000
7400 E Jolly Rogue Lane, Williams, AZ 86046
Courtesy of Melinda Theodora with Realty One Group, Mountain Desert
Sold on May 12, 2025
$620,000
2764 Kletha Trail, Flagstaff, AZ 86005
Courtesy of Katannya T Hartwell with eXp Realty
Sold on September 3, 2024
$608,000
3089 Buffalo Trail, Flagstaff, AZ 86005
Courtesy of Nancy Tabor with Realty One Group, Mountain Desert
Sold on August 24, 2026
$575,000
6260 N Dodge Avenue, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Courtesy of Kyle Yarush with Keller Williams Arizona Living Realty
Sold on December 27, 2024
$490,000
1808 S Trinidad Lane, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
Courtesy of Gary Nelson with Realty Executives of Northern Arizona
Sold on June 9, 2026
$470,000
411 S Hillcrest Drive, Snowflake, AZ 85937
Courtesy of Katannya T Hartwell with Coldwell Banker Northland
Sold on September 15, 2026
$460,000
1322 E Hatcher Drive, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
Courtesy of Kelly S Kasprzyk with Best Flagstaff Homes Realty
Sold on September 6, 2023
$435,000
2704 N East Street, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Courtesy of Katannya T Hartwell with Village Land Shoppe (Branch)
$425,000
Private Address
Sold on December 29, 2023
$305,000
3165 Round Rock Ovi, Flagstaff, AZ 86005
Courtesy of Katannya T Hartwell with Village Land Shoppe (Branch)
Sold on November 21, 2023
$269,500
1200 S Riordan Ranch Street, 65, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
Courtesy of Katannya T Hartwell with Village Land Shoppe (Branch)
Sold on September 5, 2025
$170,000
911 S Torrey Pines Drive, Williams, AZ 86046
Courtesy of Katannya T Hartwell with eXp Realty
Sold on February 1, 2024
$128,000
2452 Blue Gap Ovi Ovi, Flagstaff, AZ 86005
Whether you're buying or selling, Katannya Hartwell, known as Ms. Flagstaff, delivers exceptional service with a deep understanding of the local market. Your goals become her mission.
MAILING ADDRESS 5200 E Cortland Blvd D1 Flagstaff AZ 86004
MAILING ADDRESS 5200 E Cortland Blvd D1 Flagstaff AZ 86004